The Prime Minister, Andy Burnham, has said he will lay out the options for our future relationship with the EU to the British people, so what are those options, and why is full membership the best one?

Take me to:
Current UK Government Position
Customs Union
Single Market
EU Membership
Most aspects of the UK and EU’s current economic relationship are governed by the Trade and Cooperation Agreement, which was agreed by Boris Johnson’s government as the UK originally left the EU, taking us out of both the Customs Union and Single Market at the same time. The current Labour government, first through Sir Keir Starmer and continued by Andy Burnham, have promised to not break the red lines in Labour’s 2024 manifesto on Europe within this Parliament, which are: No Freedom of Movement, no Customs Union, and no Single Market. Instead, trapped within those red lines, the current government position is to pursue closer relations with Europe in areas such as removing border checks on food and drink exports, linking our emissions trading markets (to avoid taxes at the border), and agreeing a youth experience scheme that would allow young Brits and Europeans to live and work in each other’s countries more easily.
£12bn.
Not much. The government’s latest analysis suggests that the deals expected to be signed at the second UK-EU summit in Brussels will add 0.4% to the economy – roughly £12bn. This number pales in comparison to the economic hit estimated by the Brexit Cost project, which places the hit to the UK’s economic output in 2023 at £188.8bn. Other estimates by the OBR, Goldman Sachs, and NBER suggest that the long-term cost to the British economy is between 4-8% of GDP.
Preferred option for 18% of the public.
When asked to choose their preferred option for the UK-EU relationship, less than one in five (18%) Brits chose the UK government’s current policy of pursuing closer relations within the manifesto red lines.
Preferred option for 10% of businesses.
For businesses, continuing with current arrangements (including potential new deals on agri-food, emissions trading and youth mobility) is seen as the least favourable option. A new report published by the UK Trade and Business Commission (UKTBC) shows that the current situation is holding businesses back. Of all the available options on the table, the status quo was clearly the least popular option of the four among the business community – only 10% of businesses who responded to the consultation rated it positively. In 2025, UK goods exports to the EU were 14% lower in real terms than they were in 2019. While the upcoming UK-EU summit will address some of these trade barriers, businesses were clear that the current approach does not go far enough.
Rule-taker.
The consequence of a policy focusing on purely closer relations, within Labour’s 2024 manifesto red lines, is that Britain becomes a rule taker in the areas on which it chooses to align. While the UK will have limited decision-shaping power in the areas of EU law covered by the agreement, it will have no formal vote over those rules. That means that the UK will have to accept any changes to EU law – without having a seat at the table to vote on policy outcomes.
When the UK left the EU, it also left the trading bloc’s Customs Union. The Customs Union eliminates all tariffs on goods passing between members, and a common external tariff applies to goods from outside the Customs Union. It also removes paperwork, such as rules of origin requirements (the levels of UK or EU content a product must contain to qualify for zero tariffs).
£19bn.
Independent economic analysis by Frontier Economics, commissioned by Best for Britain, suggests that a customs union would increase the UK’s GDP by at least £19bn in the long run and boost exports by roughly £9bn each year.
Preferred option for 5% of the public.
When asked to choose their preferred UK-EU relationship option, just 5% of Brits chose the Customs Union.
Preferred option for 20% of businesses.
Only one in five businesses consulted by the UKTBC said that joining a customs union would have the most positive, or joint most positive, impact for their business. Despite removing some barriers, significant border frictions would remain. The services sector would be largely unaffected from the status quo, and goods exporters would still need to submit import and export declarations, paperwork, and be subject to potential physical checks.
Rule-taker plus.
The UK would be forced to accept tariff and trade policy set by the EU, without a seat at the table during these negotiations. It would be required to close or amend its post-Brexit trade deals. This would leave the UK as an even greater rule taker than under closer relations, leaving the government open to accusations of forgoing sovereignty.
When the UK left the EU, it also left the Single Market. The Single Market removes barriers to trade through common rules and mutual recognition of standards to enable goods and services to flow freely across the EU. As part of Single Market membership, the UK would have to accept the four freedoms: capital, goods, services, and people.
£54bn.
Independent economic analysis by Frontier Economics, commissioned by Best for Britain, suggests joining the Single Market would increase the UK’s GDP by at least £54bn in the long run and boost exports by roughly £25bn each year.
Preferred option for 6% of the public.
When asked to choose their preferred UK-EU relationship option, just 6% of Brits chose joining the Single Market.
Preferred option for 41% of businesses.
Over two-in-five businesses consulted by the UKTBC said that joining the EU’s Single Market would have the most positive impact for their business.. However, some businesses highlighted their concern over the loss of the UK’s regulatory sovereignty if the UK rejoined the EU, as the UK would become a rule taker in the majority of rules that cover the UK’s economy.
Rule-taker max.
Membership of the Single Market would mean the UK would have to follow rules set by the EU with a limited say, and no vote, on how those regulations are shaped. The UK would also become subject to rulings by the EFTA Court, and be obliged to make budget contributions. Regulations covering a large part of the UK’s economy would be set by Brussels, without the UK having a seat at the table. For a country with an economy the size of Britain, currently the fifth largest in the world, this would be an unacceptable position.
Full membership of the EU would return the UK to both the Customs Union and the Single Market, while also providing a rule-making position inside the EU by giving the UK a vote on the rules that govern the economy. It would further give the UK direct access to a set of valuable EU schemes such as the €150bn SAFE fund designed to help European governments improve their defensive capabilities in the face of Russian aggression. EU funding that communities in the UK, such as farmers and deprived areas, previously depended on would return. The return to the EU would strengthen the bloc in the face of American volatility and aggressive Chinese trading policy. As a result, by pooling together the UK’s sovereignty with our European allies, the UK could play a major role in shaping the geopolitical issues of the 21st century.
£92bn
Independent economic analysis by Frontier Economics, commissioned by Best for Britain, suggests joining full membership could increase the UK’s GDP by at least £92bn in the long run and boost exports by roughly £43bn each year. Membership would also benefit every region of the economy – delivering growth in every postcode of the UK. The parts of the UK most affected by Brexit are the country’s former industrial heartlands. As a result, full membership will benefit these areas, such as the Midlands and the North East, most. This is a vital aspect in the much-needed re-industrialisation of the UK and the rebalancing of long-term regional inequality, both of which are priorities for the Burnham government.
Preferred option for 35% of the public.
When asked to choose their preferred UK-EU relationship option, EU membership was the most popular in all but four British constituencies, with 35% of Brits choosing the policy as their preferred option. Twice as many as the next closest option. Polling surrounding the UK’s readmission into Europe has been clear for some time. A recent poll published by YouGov showed that 63% of Brits think Brexit has been a failure, compared to just 9% who view it as a success. The latest poll on a potential referendum suggests that two-thirds (65%) of voters favour rejoining, compared to a third (35%) who would vote to stay out.
Preferred option for 76% of businesses.
Over three-quarters of businesses consulted by the UKTBC said that EU membership would have the most positive, or joint most positive, impact for their business. Following their consultation, the UKTBC argued that membership removes nearly all barriers businesses raised. Furthermore, membership could provide certainty on a range of issues, from access to funding to inclusion in EU-only initiatives such as ‘Made in Europe’.
Rule maker
The UK would become a top rule maker, returning alongside France and Germany to become one of the most dominant voices in the creation and shaping of new EU legislation. The UK could put their own judges on the European Court of Justice, and could begin to shape the EU from the inside – particularly on issues such as AI. By pooling together the UK’s sovereignty with 27 other European countries, the UK would vastly improve its global standing and power on the world stage. In an increasingly multipolar world driven by transborder issues, collective unity and strength are the only way in which Britain could retain any true form of sovereignty against the likes of Russia, China, and the US.